The US is wrong to ban pay for bone-marrow donors – Standard-Examiner
Posted: February 24, 2017 at 6:43 pm
(c) 2017, Bloomberg View.
Two years ago, Doreen Flynn of Lewiston, Maine, won her case against the U.S. government, successfully arguing that bone-marrow donors should be able to receive compensation.
Flynn, a mother of three girls who are afflicted with a rare, hereditary blood disease called Fanconis anemia, has a strong interest in bone-marrow transplantation. At the time of the court ruling, her oldest daughter, Jordan, 14, had already received a transplant, and one of the younger twins, Jorja, was expected to need one in a few years.
Locating a marrow donor is often a needle-in-a-haystack affair. The odds that two random individuals will have the same tissue type are less than 1 in 10,000, and the chances are much lower for blacks. Among the precious few potential donors who are matched, nearly half dont follow through with the actual donation. Too often, patients dont survive the time it takes to hunt for another donor.
Allowing compensation for donations could enlarge the pool of potential donors and increase the likelihood that compatible donors will follow through. So the ruling by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit was promising news for the 12,000 people with cancer and blood diseases currently looking for a marrow donor. (James F. Childress, an ethicist at the University of Virginia, and I submitted an amicus brief in the case.)
Soon after the verdict, Shaka Mitchell, a lawyer in Nashville, Tennessee, and co-founder of the nonprofit MoreMarrowDonors.org, began collecting funds to underwrite $3,000 donor benefits, which were to be given as scholarships, housing allowances or gifts to charity.
Mitchell also invited a team of economists to evaluate the effects of the ruling on peoples willingness to join a registry and to donate when they are found to be a match. The researchers were to specifically assess whether cash payments would be any more or less persuasive than noncash rewards or charitable donations.
Now comes the bad news. On Oct. 2, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services proposed a new rule that would overturn the Ninth Circuits decision. The government proposes designating a specific form of bone marrow -- circulating bone-marrow stem cells derived from blood -- as a kind of donation that, under the 1984 National Organ Transplant Act, cannot be compensated. If this rule goes into effect (the public comment period ends today), anyone who pays another person for donating these cells would be subject to as much as five years in prison and a $50,000 fine.
The problem with this rule is that donating bone marrow is not like donating an essential organ. Indeed, the Ninth Circuit based its decision on the fact that modern bone-marrow procurement, a process known as apheresis, is more akin to drawing blood. In the early 1980s, when the transplant act was written, the process was more demanding, involving anesthesia and the use of large, hollow needles to extract marrow from a donors hip. But today, more than two-thirds of marrow donations are done via apheresis. Blood is taken from a donors arm, the bone-marrow stem cells are filtered out, and the blood is then returned to the donor through a needle in the other arm.
The Ninth Circuit panel held that these filtered stem cells are merely components of blood -- no different from blood-derived plasma, platelets and clotting factors, for which donor compensation is allowed.
The strongest opposition to compensation comes from the National Marrow Donor Program, the Minneapolis-based nonprofit that maintains the nations largest donor registry. Michael Boo, the programs chief strategy officer, says of reimbursement, Is that what we want people to be motivated by?
The problem with this logic is that altruism has proven insufficient to motivate enough people to give marrow and, as a result, people die.
HHS is presumably under pressure from the National Marrow Donor Program. The department does not otherwise explain its proposed rule except to claim that compensation runs afoul of the transplant acts intent to ban commodification of human stem cells and to curb opportunities for coercion and exploitation, encourage altruistic donation and decrease the likelihood of disease transmission.
But how could such concerns plausibly apply to marrow stem cells and not to blood plasma? The process of collecting plasma is safe: No serious infection has been transmitted in plasma-derived products in nearly two decades, according to the Plasma Protein Therapeutics Association. Strenuous screening and testing in a robust regulatory environment, coupled with voluntary industry standards and sophisticated manufacturing processes, have created what has been called the safest blood product available today.
Outlawing compensation for stem blood cells but not mature blood cells might even violate the constitutional guarantee of equal protection of the law, according to Jeff Rowes, a lawyer at the Institute for Justice, which represented Flynn.
HHS should withdraw its proposal. Ideally, Congress should thwart future regulatory mischief by amending the National Organ Transplant Act to stipulate that marrow stem cells are not organs.
Each year, 2,000 to 3,000 Americans in need of marrow transplants die waiting for a match. Altruism is a virtue, but clearly it is not a dependable motive for marrow donation.
---
Satel, a psychiatrist and a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, is a co-author of Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience. To contact the editor responsible for this story: Mary Duenwald at mduenwald@bloomberg.net.
marrow-donor-comment
Keywords: SATEL-OP-ED-MARROWDONORS
Here is the original post:
The US is wrong to ban pay for bone-marrow donors - Standard-Examiner
- Bone Marrow Stem Cells [Last Updated On: June 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 24th, 2011]
- Stem cells in bone marrow are being used to treat EB [Last Updated On: June 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 24th, 2011]
- Stem cells in bone marrow are being used to treat EB [Last Updated On: June 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 25th, 2011]
- Peripheral Artery Disease: Can Progenitor Cells Help? [Last Updated On: June 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 25th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Producing Insulin [Last Updated On: June 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 25th, 2011]
- Stem Cells Reversing Endothelial Senescence [Last Updated On: June 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 25th, 2011]
- Peripheral Artery Disease: Can Progenitor Cells Help? [Last Updated On: June 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 26th, 2011]
- Science behind Enhancing Adult Stem Cells for wellbeing [Last Updated On: June 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 26th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Applications [Last Updated On: June 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 26th, 2011]
- Immune Modulation by Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stem Cells [Last Updated On: June 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 26th, 2011]
- Expansion of Stem Cells by Valproic Acid [Last Updated On: June 27th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 27th, 2011]
- STEM CELLS FOR MACULAR DEGENERATION Sam Smith's story.wmv [Last Updated On: June 27th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 27th, 2011]
- StemLife's First Cord Blood Stem Cell Transplant Recipient [Last Updated On: June 28th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 28th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Differentiation to Heart? YES [Last Updated On: June 28th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 28th, 2011]
- STEM CELLS FOR OTHER USES Interview with Sam Smith.wmv [Last Updated On: June 29th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 29th, 2011]
- StemLife's First Cord Blood Stem Cell Transplant Recipient [Last Updated On: June 30th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 30th, 2011]
- Bone marrow transplantation HD, ENG subtitles [Last Updated On: July 3rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 3rd, 2011]
- Cord Blood and Bone Marrow Stem Cells for Liver Failure [Last Updated On: July 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 4th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Applications [Last Updated On: July 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 4th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Producing Insulin [Last Updated On: July 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 5th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Donation [Last Updated On: July 6th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 6th, 2011]
- Adult Stem Cells May Target and Repair Heart Attack Damage [Last Updated On: July 6th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 6th, 2011]
- Stem cells used for medical treatment [Last Updated On: July 7th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 7th, 2011]
- Bone marrow transplantation HD, ENG subtitles [Last Updated On: July 8th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 8th, 2011]
- Adult Stem Cells May Target and Repair Heart Attack Damage [Last Updated On: July 8th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 8th, 2011]
- From Surgical Repair to Stem Cell Repair: A Surgeon's Journey by Leonard Smith MD, FACS [Last Updated On: July 13th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 13th, 2011]
- STEM CELLS - Bone Marrow Stem Cells (Balzitt).flv [Last Updated On: July 14th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 14th, 2011]
- Spirulina DLA Naturals [Last Updated On: July 15th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 15th, 2011]
- Spirulina DLA Naturals [Last Updated On: July 16th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 16th, 2011]
- Insidermedicine In 60 - January 6, 2011 [Last Updated On: July 16th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 16th, 2011]
- Christian Drapeau Talk About - Adult Stem Cells and StemEnhance./StemTech [Last Updated On: July 18th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 18th, 2011]
- The potential of stem cells [Last Updated On: July 18th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 18th, 2011]
- Insidermedicine In 60 - March 11, 2011 [Last Updated On: July 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 20th, 2011]
- Blind Girl get's cure you need to see to believe" [Last Updated On: July 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 23rd, 2011]
- STEM CELLS - Bone Marrow Stem Cells (Balzitt).flv [Last Updated On: July 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 23rd, 2011]
- Expansion of Stem Cells by Valproic Acid [Last Updated On: July 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 23rd, 2011]
- Blind Girl get's cure you need to see to believe" [Last Updated On: July 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 24th, 2011]
- LifeCell in Kalaignar Seithigal,Sun News [Last Updated On: July 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 26th, 2011]
- Science behind Enhancing Adult Stem Cells for wellbeing [Last Updated On: July 27th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 27th, 2011]
- Why treatment results vary after stem cell treatment [Last Updated On: July 27th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 27th, 2011]
- From Surgical Repair to Stem Cell Repair: A Surgeon's Journey by Leonard Smith MD, FACS [Last Updated On: August 3rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 3rd, 2011]
- Insidermedicine In 60 - March 11, 2011 [Last Updated On: August 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 4th, 2011]
- Why STEM-Enhance? [Last Updated On: August 10th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 10th, 2011]
- Stem cells Transplatation in Completed Paralyze Dog. [Last Updated On: August 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 12th, 2011]
- Stem cells Transplatation in Completed Paralyze Dog. [Last Updated On: August 15th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 15th, 2011]
- Best natural skin care serum using stem cell technology [Last Updated On: August 19th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 19th, 2011]
- "Bone Marrow Stem Cells" Donald Kohn [Last Updated On: August 29th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 29th, 2011]
- The potential of stem cells [Last Updated On: August 31st, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 31st, 2011]
- Manatee man is paralyzed, but still plenty hopeful [Last Updated On: September 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 4th, 2011]
- Stem Cells and Bone Marrow Transplants by Dipnarine Maharaj MD PhD [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- MS Cure - Introduction to stem cell bone marrow transplant in Australia [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow/Stem Cell Transplantation: An Introduction, With Sonali Smith, MD [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- Cancer Update: Autologus Stem Cell (Bone Marrow) Transplant [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Transplant Live from Top US Hospital [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- Adult Stem Cell Mobilization from Bone Marrow (Animation) [Last Updated On: September 6th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 6th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow / Stem Cell Transplant Recovery Fund [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Expansion by HOXB4 and p21 Knock Out [Last Updated On: September 10th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 10th, 2011]
- Adult Stem Cell Mobilization from Bone Marrow (Animation) [Last Updated On: September 10th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 10th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow/Stem Cell Transplant [Last Updated On: September 10th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 10th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow/Stem Cell Transplant [Last Updated On: September 11th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 11th, 2011]
- Macular Degeneration Improved With Stem Cells [Last Updated On: September 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 12th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Transplant India,Bone Marrow Transplant India,Sickle Cell Anemia Treatment India [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2011]
- Nurses Discuss Special Bonds With Bone Marrow and Stem Cell Transplant Patients [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2011]
- Becoming a Blood Stem Cell Donor [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow and Stem Cell Transplant Patients Share Their Stories [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2011]
- LittleBigPlanet 2 - (WIP) Stem Cell Sackboy Bone Marrow Bugaloo [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2011]
- LittleBigPlanet 2 - Stem Cell Sackboy Quarter 4 Update (Bone Marrow Bugaloo) [Last Updated On: September 22nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 22nd, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Transplant Program Continues to Grow, Make a Difference [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Can Stem Cell Prolotherapy or Bone Marrow Prolotherapy help articular cartilage defects? [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Multiple Sclerosis, Stem Cells, and Hope, Part 2 [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Transplant Program Continues to Grow, Make a Difference [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- How to be an Anthony Nolan blood stem cell donor [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Stem Cells extracted from bone marrow [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Calum's stem cell donation for Anthony Nolan [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Cancer Update: Autologus Stem Cell (Bone Marrow) Transplant [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2011]
- Bone Marrow - Stem Cell Prolotherapy [Last Updated On: September 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 24th, 2011]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Aspiration and Re-Injection with PRP for Osteoarthritis by Dr Adelson [Last Updated On: September 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 24th, 2011]
- Mesenchymal stem cells and marrow stromal cells---2nd--- [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Injections - Bone Marrow Prolotherapy - treatment for arthritis [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2011]
- Chat w/ Dr. Maharaj, founder of S. FL. Bone Marrow/Stem Cell Transplant Institute [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2011]